Though our posts are supposed to be
related to the book, I initially want to mention the fact that much of this
book was based upon the real-life experiences of the author, a Spokane Native,
Sherman Alexie. His intention in writing this young adult novel was to be able
to portray a life-like depiction of what reservation life was truly like. By
presenting an autobiographical depiction, Alexie was able to relate many themes
within this book to the experiences that happen within adolescents lives.
Compared to
some of the other books we have read in this class, I felt that there were more
themes than just one or two within this book that need to be discussed. Arnold
Spirit Jr, or even the readers, are taken through a roller-coaster of themes and
ideas that young adolescents need to be exposed to. Although some reviewers or
book critics may be against these themes, I believe that Sherman Alexie wrote
about masturbation, racism, drugs and alcohol, bullying, poverty, death, and
even anorexia for a reason. Although I think limiting a theme could possibly
help students really understand an issue or topic easier, I felt that many
themes were included to possibly reach more kids than just a selected group of
individuals struggling with a problem. Random thought, it seems like
differentiated instruction. He seems to use a variety themes throughout the
book to get all kinds of readers involved and interested. Because of this, I absolutely would teach
this book within a classroom, and yes, it absolutely relates to young adolescents.
However, let me take a step back and say that although I would enjoy teaching
this book, I would find it quite challenging at the same time. For example, I
would hate to overstep my boundaries. I think as teacher you just need to make
sure you do not disrespect any students that struggle with some of these
issues.
What I
found interesting about this book was the way that Alexie introduced themes. If
anybody other than the professor is reading this, don’t you agree that majority
of the issues and themes throughout the book are discussed or brought up
through Juniors ideas or thoughts of stereotypes? With this question in mind, I
think the idea of finding ones self needs to be discussed. It seems that the
role of identity was considered throughout the book based upon which themes
that I listed above were encountered by specific characters. It seemed to me
that students that read this book could do the same. Considering that I believe
that this book has many themes that can relate to several young adolescents, I
rate this book and A (which is my highest grade given yet). One way, personally,
that I loved this book was because we were reading about two characters. Not
only the life of Junior, but the real life of Sherman Alexie. Though some young
adults could struggle finding the connections between the character and the
author, I think that as a teacher, an authors biography lesson would be
relevant and very beneficial before reading this book, or maybe even after.
*This book was fantastic. An “A” book, my favorite book yet,
and a book that can shine within the hearts of many young adolescents.
I'm so glad you liked this one--and yay for differentiated instruction! What an interesting and nice parallel you raise with that!
ReplyDelete